natural sciences

Butterflies that eat ants

A Formica ant milking sweet nectar from a Plebejus idas caterpillar. Ants are willing to protect butterfly larvae for the sake of this juice. Author/source: Margus Vilbas
A Formica ant milking sweet nectar from a Plebejus idas caterpillar. Ants are willing to protect butterfly larvae for the sake of this juice. Author/source: Margus Vilbas

Would you trust ants to raise your children? Beautiful small butterflies from the genus Maculinea do it and so, in the course of evolution, one of the weirdest forms of cohabitating species has developed – right here in Estonia.

Butterflies are disappearing globally, primarily due to the global climate change, land use intensification and cessation of traditional management practices. Although being one of the most studied insect groups in the world, there are species that are difficult to protect even in habitats seemingly suitable for them. This is probably due to the fact that some of them have managed to hide a special secret, vitally important for them.

The habitat requirements and distribution patterns of the myrmecophilous butterflies (i.e. they associate with ants) from the genus Maculinea were addressed in a doctoral thesis: “Biotic interactions affecting habitat use of myrmecophilous butterflies in Northern Europe”, defended recently in the Tartu University Institute of Ecology and Earth Sciences by Margus Vilbas, aiming to expand existing knowledge concerning the geographic variation of habitats of the endangered Maculinea butterflies to the northernmost populations known for these species. Particular emphasis was placed on identifying the host specificity of the studied butterflies.

Phengaris arion uses wild thyme (Thymus serpyllum) as a food plant. Author: Margus Vilbas

Most of the lycaenid butterflies are myrmecophiles – at a certain period in their life (predominantly in their larval stages), they are associated with ants. The fundamental nature of these associations is that caterpillars provide ants with sugar-rich secretions in exchange for vital protection against predators and parasitoids. Most relationships are mutually beneficial, and the presence of ants is not essential for the survival of butterflies.

However, there are butterfly species for which ants are indispensable, so they cannot survive without certain ant species being present. Some of them(e.g. species from the genus Maculinea) are so specialized that after the time spent on the food plant they infiltrate into the ant nest where they continue to live as obligate parasites of ants. There also exist examples of generalist herbivores that are in obligate mutualistic relationships with specific host ants (e.g. species belonging to the genus Plebejus). In the colony, the caterpillars become social parasites of ants. While some species (e.g. Phengaris alcon) manipulate worker ants into feeding them, the others (e.g. P. arion) feed directly as predators of ants and their brood. Also, when staying in the colony, caterpillars keep providing ants with sugary nectar, in expectation of which the addicted worker ants carry out orders from their new masters (butterflies).

The secret life of Phengaris

There are two species of Phengaris present in Estonia – P. arion and P. alcon. The butterflies inhabit open semi-natural calcareous grasslands where females lay distinctive and resilient eggs on the flower heads and leaves of the specific host plants.  P. arion, depending on the area, uses wild thyme (Thymus serpyllum) or wild marjoram (Origanum vulgare) as a larval food plant. P. alcon feeds exclusively on star gentian (Gentiana cruciata).

They are in a hurry, as the lifespan of Maculinea adults does not last much longer than 3–4 days. Purple caterpillars hatch approximately one week later and start feeding on the flowers and seeds of the food plant. During about 2–3 weeks that caterpillars spend on the plant, they acquire only 1% of their final body mass!

After that, things get more interesting.. In particular, in the fourth (final) instar the caterpillars descend to the ground to wait for Myrmica worker ants to carry them into their colony. It is critical for the survival of the butterfly to end up in the colony of suitable host ant species! Namely, some of the Maculinea populations are extremely specific, being able to go through the life cycle only in the colonies of just one or few Myrmica species. Maculinea larvae use chemical mimicry to infiltrate into the ant society, preventing worker ants from distinguishing them from their own larvae.

P. alcon eggs on the leaves of G. cruciata. Author: Margus Vilbas

Myrmica lonae worker tending for full grown (prepupal) Phengaris arion caterpillar. Author: Margus Vilbas

In the colony, the larvae stay either 10 or 22 months due to their polymorphic growth, which means that part of them evolve into adults in one year, while the other part evolves in two years.

Larvae acquire more than 99% of their body weight when living in a colony. By the way, one small P. arion larva needs approximately 230 large Myrmica sabuleti caterpillars to reach the adult stage! Unfortunately, most of the Myrmica colonies are not large enough to raise even one P. arion individual to its adult stage. The situation is somewhat simpler for P. alcon as carrying capacities of Myrmica colonies for so called “cuckoo” species are generally higher due to their less harmful feeding strategy.

By exhausting the ants, the butterflies are putting themselves in danger

Numerous populations of Phengaris butterflies are suffering significant declines or have even gone to extinction due to their complex life cycle and susceptibility to environmental changes. For example, Phengaris arion is listed in the Estonian Red Data Book as “threatened”, while Phengaris alcon is the only ‘critically endangered’ butterfly species facing extinction in Estonia.

Two other obligately myrmecophilous butterfly species are known to be present in Estonia – Plebejus argus and P. idas. These two common lycaenids being abundant all over the country feed on numerous species and genera of food plants. However, they are unique among European Lepidoptera as they are the only known obligately myrmecophilous mutualists in the region. More precisely, caterpillars of P. argus are reported to exclusively associate with Lasius spp. while P. idas shows high specificity for Formica spp.

In conclusion, the simultaneous existence of two spatially overlapping resources – suitable food plants and ant species – has to be taken into account while planning conservation practices for obligately myrmecophilous butterflies. Moreover, specific interactions with ants are often a key factor to consider. Accordingly, not rare are the cases when population declines have resulted from the inappropriate management of otherwise healthy habitats.

M. Vilbas counting P. alcon eggs on Gentiana cruciata plant. Author: Margus Vilbas

The translation of this article from Estonian Public Broadcasting science news portal Novaator was funded by the European Regional Development Fund through Estonian Research Council.

Read more

Get our monthly newsletterBe up-to-date with all the latest news and upcoming events